Borrow somebody else's eyes

Overview

The hardest user to test for is the one who isn't you

The hardest user to test for is the one who isn't you. You know the product. You know which button to press, which menu hides the setting, which field accepts that quirky format. You haven't seen the empty state in months because your account isn't empty. Persona testing is the discipline of borrowing other eyes — pretending to be a first-time user, an enterprise admin with a hundred teammates, a customer on a flip phone, a person whose job depends on getting this right but who has never seen this screen before. The product doesn't change. Your eyes do. And what you notice changes with them.

Break it down

Eight seconds of hover on a screen I'd walked past a thousand times

I sat with a customer once who was setting up our product for the first time. I'd built parts of it. I knew it cold. But watching her, I saw her hover for eight full seconds on a screen I'd never registered as confusing — the empty workspace state, with no projects in it yet. The screen made perfect sense if you knew what a workspace was. She didn't. There was nothing on the screen telling her what to do next. I'd walked past that screen a thousand times because my workspace had always had projects in it. Her eyes, for thirty minutes, were the best test I'd run all year.

A little simpler

How you can test on your own when you're not a manual QA tester:

Practical tips for anyone who wants to try to QA on their own

  • Create a brand new account and use the product from scratch — the empty state is where most products quietly fail

  • Imagine three users: someone new, someone power, someone in a hurry. Try each one's path.

  • Better yet: actually watch a real user use it. Five minutes of watching beats five hours of testing.

  • Ask the simplest question: what does this assume the user already knows?

Got an idea for our next issue?

Support Audubon & Receive a Gift

Rufous Hummingbird. Photo: Nathan Wall/Audubon Photography Awards

Become a member of the National Audubon Society today and receive our award-winning magazine as a thank-you. Every three months, enjoy stories about protecting birds and the places they need, delivered to your mailbox.

Keep Reading